Living Without Running Water

Public shock, anger over issue evaporate

By Mary Agnes Welch 5 minute read Saturday, Nov. 5, 2011

WHERE’S the outrage?

It’s been a year since the Winnipeg Free Press first highlighted the damage to health and human dignity caused by the lack of running water in 1,400 First Nations homes. The series of stories spawned hundreds of emails, online comments and letters to the editor, many asking what action average people could take to solve the problem.

But since then, a small handful of advocacy campaigns have largely failed to galvanize public opinion, few charitable organizations have stepped up to tackle the problem and the federal government is under no sustained pressure to provide essential services to First Nations mired in Third World conditions

“All that energy and public attention just dissipated,” said Laurel Gardiner, director of the Manitoba office of the Frontiers Foundation, an aboriginal charitable agency that’s piloting a home retrofit program in Island Lake.

Advertisement

Advertise With Us

Weather

Nov. 15, 6 AM: 2°c Windy Nov. 15, 12 PM: 8°c Windy

Winnipeg MB

3°C, Cloudy with wind

Full Forecast

Lottery for a life

By Mary Agnes Welch 7 minute read Preview

Lottery for a life

By Mary Agnes Welch 7 minute read Saturday, Nov. 5, 2011

ST. THERESA POINT -- Zach Harper waited 75 years for a house with running water and a flush toilet.

One week after Harper got it, he died.

Asked last year whether he believed the federal government would ever fund proper plumbing for him, the widower was skeptical.

"He'll ask God that question," said his son-in-law Geordie Rae, translating the elder's Oji-Cree.

Read
Saturday, Nov. 5, 2011

Zach Harper waited 75 years to live in a house with running water. He died a week after his family home at St. Theresa Point First Nation was retrofitted to include running water, a kitchen sink and a proper bathroom.

Reserves to get upgrade

By Mary Agnes Welch 5 minute read Preview

Reserves to get upgrade

By Mary Agnes Welch 5 minute read Tuesday, Oct. 25, 2011

Nine First Nations with the diciest drinking water will get upgrades to their treatment plants and pipes over the next four years -- good news for a province plagued with water woes.

Anna Fontaine, Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada's regional director for Manitoba, says nine bands, such as Hollow Water and Peguis First Nations, that have "high-risk" water systems will see cash for upgrades to ensure their drinking water doesn't make band members sick.

"Those aren't the only ones that are being done," Fontaine said. "Those are just the ones that are high-risk."

The move follows a damning federal report released in July that assessed every water and sewage treatment system on Canadian reserves and found nearly 40 per cent of water plants were so troubled they posed a high risk to human health.

Read
Tuesday, Oct. 25, 2011

JOE BRYKSA / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Anna Fontaine, of Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development, says nine Manitoba First Nations will see their water and sewage systems improved over four years.

Misery and indifference

By Mary Agnes Welch 6 minute read Preview

Misery and indifference

By Mary Agnes Welch 6 minute read Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011

WASAGAMACK -- Richard Andrews is a man of few words and a fan of understatement.

Standing in the gloom of his sagging trailer, he surveys the muddy floor, the goopy flypaper dangling from the kitchen ceiling, the piles of dirty clothes and the dishes stacked in a sink with no faucet. Graffiti and children's scribbles cover what remains of the walls, around holes that allow pink insulation to peek out. It's freezing in the winter, mouldy when the furnace kicks in and worse than even the slummiest apartment in Winnipeg.

"This place should be condemned already," Andrews says with a shrug.

Andrews lives, often with five other adults and his seven or eight grandchildren in what is likely the most squalid home on the reserve with the most pressing sanitation problems in the province. There is no running water to wash clothes, bathe the gaggle of muddy toddlers, do dishes or keep the floors clean. The family shares a slop pail, lined with a garbage bag, in what passes for a bathroom.

Read
Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011

A grandson plays in Richard Andrews' squalid trailer: 'This place should be condemned already.'

Easy to judge, difficult to escape

By Mary Agnes Welch / My Opinion 6 minute read Preview

Easy to judge, difficult to escape

By Mary Agnes Welch / My Opinion 6 minute read Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011

When we stepped into Richard Andrews' home in Wasagamack, we had only one question: Why the hell are you living here?

For Free Press photojournalist Joe Bryksa, who has visited two dozen homes without running water all across this province, it was the worst he'd seen. Dirty clothes piled everywhere, floors gritty with mud, window frames crusted with mould. Most walls were covered with scribbles, and every piece of furniture looked like something left beside a dumpster.

There are six adults and seven kids under the age of nine who live, off-and-on, in the old trailer, with no indoor toilet or running water. A few of the toddlers were so caked with mud I, to my own shame, paused for a second before lifting one up to help him onto a rickety porch in a yard strewn with garbage.

Why would anyone allow their children to live in a home like this? Why not pay for a water tank or a septic field? Or find another house? Or move to Winnipeg? Or Thompson?

Read
Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011

Up to seven kids at a time live in Richard Andrews' derelict home. Why do people put up with such surroundings? The answers are complicated, say experts.

Degrading third-world conditions one more hurdle for disabled man on reserve

By Mary Agnes Welch 7 minute read Preview

Degrading third-world conditions one more hurdle for disabled man on reserve

By Mary Agnes Welch 7 minute read Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011

ST. THERESA POINT -- A little whistle means Kevin Taylor has managed to hoist himself over the slop pail by himself and doesn't need his mother's help.

Taylor, a shy 30-year-old who has cerebral palsy and can't walk on his own, has a few bathroom options in his St. Theresa Point home, and they're all a humiliating hassle.

He can use his crutches to get from his perch on the living room sofa to the small room that serves as the bathroom. That's where the new slop pail is parked under the chair-like commode, near the plastic basin that serves as a makeshift sink. If Taylor's in a hurry, though, he usually drags his body down the hall in a scooching motion he's perfected and heaves himself up onto the commode.

 

Read
Saturday, Oct. 22, 2011

Alice Taylor with her son Kevin, who has cerebral palsy. She has filed a human rights complaint over the lack of programs for disabled people on the reserve. Below, Kevin Taylor often has to get to the bathroom by crawling.

Safe water a human right: Canadians

2 minute read Monday, Nov. 15, 2010

ALMOST all Canadians believe clean water should be guaranteed as a human right, according to a poll to be released in Winnipeg this month by the Trudeau Foundation and the University of Manitoba.

Of those surveyed, 96 per cent said water should be a guaranteed right, while only two per cent said it should not -- the strongest response to any of the six emerging rights the pollsters proposed.

"The public is concerned about this question of water and environmental problems much more than we think," said Trudeau Foundation president Pierre-Gerlier Forest. "I find it quite encouraging."

The support for clean water as a human right was solid across income groups, education levels and regions of the country. Adults under the age of 45 were a bit more supportive, as were women.

Sewer superhero

By Helen Fallding 6 minute read Monday, Nov. 15, 2010

FISHER RIVER -- At midnight on a bitter Manitoba winter night when the sewage plant on a remote First Nation breaks down, who you gonna call?

Troubleshooter Ken Mattes.

He has installed a water plant for the Canadian Forces in Egypt and built warm flush toilets for soldiers cleaning up radioactive debris from a Soviet satellite that crashed in the Arctic.

"We had running water in a week."

Water service survey

By Helen Fallding 5 minute read Monday, Nov. 15, 2010

Engineers have fanned out across Canada to evaluate the state of water and wastewater services on almost every one of the country's 610 First Nations.

The $9-million assessment comes in the wake of a long list of damning government reports, issued over more than a decade, that warned about the health consequences of not solving reserve water woes.

The project, co-ordinated by Winnipeg engineer Heather MacKenzie, is supposed to help the federal government pin down what it will cost to bring up to standard every First Nations water and sewage plant in Canada.

A similar assessment in 2003 pegged the cost at about $1.7 billion over five years. Almost that much was spent by 2008, but 117 First Nations still have to boil their drinking water.

Billions spent

By Helen Fallding 6 minute read Monday, Nov. 15, 2010

NO one can accuse the Canadian government of ignoring water and waste-water systems on First Nations over the last 15 years.

The Library of Parliament estimates $3.5 billion was spent between 1995 and 2008 and hundreds of millions more have been committed since.

After that kind of staggering expenditure, why is tap water on so many First Nations unfit to drink and why do half the homes in Island Lake lack running water?

Then-Indian Affairs minister Chuck Strahl pretty much admitted this spring his department cannot keep up with infrastructure needs on reserves -- unless there's a major change in how projects are funded.

Stuck with the flow

By Helen Fallding 5 minute read Preview

Stuck with the flow

By Helen Fallding 5 minute read Saturday, Nov. 13, 2010

RESEARCHERS are collecting samples of drinking water from a dozen randomly chosen Manitoba First Nations to test for traces of metals, such as mercury, that can slowly poison.

"I mentioned to them I wanted water samples across from the old garbage dump because that's upstream of where our water intake is," said Hollow Water Coun. Denelle Bushie.

He's also worried about what might be coming downstream from the Bissett gold mines via the Wanipigow River that supplies drinking water for Hollow Water residents.

Northlands First Nation has similar concerns about uranium mines across the Saskatchewan border.

Read
Saturday, Nov. 13, 2010

JOE.BRYKSA@FREEPRESS.MB.CA
Coun. Denelle Bushie stands by the Wanipigow River, the source for drinking water for Hollow Water First Nation.

Boiling mad

6 minute read Preview

Boiling mad

6 minute read Saturday, Nov. 13, 2010

HOLLOW WATER FIRST NATION -- Water detective Clarence Peebles is on the case. Every time the water plant operator sees a suspicious puddle -- day or night, his weary wife confirms -- he leaps out of his truck and scoops up some water.

If a test strip dipped in the water turns pink, Peebles knows somewhere under the ground is a pipe leaking his precious chlorine-treated water.

A single pipe break or a running toilet can be enough to overwhelm the community's aging treatment plant, designed 20 years ago to supply a maximum population of 720.

About 1,000 people now live on the Hollow Water reserve, but it will likely be 2015 before their treatment plant is expanded enough to meet local needs.

Read
Saturday, Nov. 13, 2010

JOE.BRYKSA@FREEPRESS.MB.CA
Grandmother Shayle Moneyas with grandchild Xavier. A doctor said the baby’s impetigo skin condi­tion is probably not related to the contaminated water flowing through Hollow Water’s taps, but Moneyas sometimes gets stomach cramps from drinking it.

‘A slap in the face’

By Helen Fallding 6 minute read Preview

‘A slap in the face’

By Helen Fallding 6 minute read Friday, Nov. 12, 2010

Indian and Northern Affairs Minister John Duncan promises to let First Nations help rewrite a proposed drinking-water law that outraged aboriginal leaders and the Liberal Opposition when it was introduced in the Senate in May.

No law governs the quality of drinking water on First Nations, so no one has the authority to set standards and enforce them -- one of the reasons almost one in five First Nations has contaminated tap water.

Former Indian and Northern Affairs minister Chuck Strahl tried to close the gaping legal hole this spring by having aboriginal Sen. Patrick Brazeau introduce the Safe Drinking Water for First Nations Act in the Senate.

But First Nations say the bill is deeply flawed because it explicitly overrides their treaty rights and could lead them to be fined for problems largely out of their control.

Read
Friday, Nov. 12, 2010

JOE.BRYKSA@FREEPRESS.MB.CA
Clyde Lonefoot, 19, gets a pail of treated water at one of the fresh-water delivery stations in St. Theresa Point First Nation.

Red Sucker Lake water woes boil over

By Mia Rabson 4 minute read Preview

Red Sucker Lake water woes boil over

By Mia Rabson 4 minute read Wednesday, Nov. 3, 2010

OTTAWA -- The chief of a northern Manitoba First Nation says his reserve is nearing a water crisis after more than half of the band's residents were cut off from a primitive water system.

On Monday, Red Sucker Lake Chief Larry Knott ordered residents to stop using water from the holding tanks beneath their homes after four tanks were randomly tested and all contained bacteria.

More than 100 houses in Red Sucker Lake use the tanks, which are filled by trucks with clean water from the community water-treatment plant. The water from the tanks is piped to taps inside the homes with electric pumps.

They are the only homes with any vestige of running water in Red Sucker Lake, a fly-in community 700 kilometres northeast of Winnipeg. The rest of the residents get their water by filling pails at the nursing station and walking or driving back to their houses.

Read
Wednesday, Nov. 3, 2010

JOE.BRYKSA@FREEPRESS.MB.CA
Annie Dan (left) and Annabella Dan collect lake water at Red Sucker Lake.

Less water than a refugee camp

By Helen Fallding 4 minute read Preview

Less water than a refugee camp

By Helen Fallding 4 minute read Saturday, Oct. 30, 2010

ST. THERESA POINT -- Geordie Rae traipses wearily through the bush to a neighbour’s house a couple of times a day, panting under the weight of a plastic pail of water.

The five-minute walk with a used oil or chemical bucket that weighs 19 kilograms when full is too much for the kids to manage, and the family’s vehicle isn’t running.

In Island Lake, the dirt roads dissolve into deep, muddy ruts in the rain, making expensive four-wheel-drive trucks and sport utility vehicles the only practical option. When you’re unemployed and covering astronomical grocery bills for food that has to be flown in, it’s hard to afford a taxi ride to the nearest community water tap.

Social assistance delivers six pails of water every week for Rae’s father-in­law Zach Harper because he’s an elder. Everyone else fends for themselves.

Read
Saturday, Oct. 30, 2010

JOE.BRYKSA@FREEPRESS.MB.CA
Zach Harper shows his scars from operations related to tuberculosis. It’s hard for the elder to look after himself without running water.

Poor sanitation, poor health

By Helen Fallding 4 minute read Preview

Poor sanitation, poor health

By Helen Fallding 4 minute read Saturday, Oct. 30, 2010

ST. THERESA POINT -- Baby Jacob’s face is covered in crusting sores that look painful, but he sleeps in his mother’s arms, beautiful moccasins made by his great-grandmother on his dangling feet.

Young mother Valene Flett waits patiently with her adopted son at the nursing station.

Nurses aren’t certain what Jacob’s itchy skin condition is — eczema, perhaps — but they’ve told Flett the best way to help the child’s skin heal.

“Keep him clean all the time,” she said.

Read
Saturday, Oct. 30, 2010

JOE.BRYKSA@FREEPRESS.MB.CA
Valene Flett is worried about her son Jacob’s rash and if it will heal.

LOAD MORE