First Nations policing is an essential service By: Editorial Posted: 7:00 PM CDT Tuesday, Oct. 4, 2022

Opinion

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 03/10/2022 (767 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

If a home in Winnipeg is invaded by someone with a weapon, it’s expected police will rush to the crime scene within minutes. If the same scenario happens on a Manitoba First Nation, police response can be measured in hours, maybe days.

A total of 45 of 63 Manitoba First Nations do not have dedicated, in-community policing services. It’s a critical shortcoming that could be rectified if federal Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino fulfills his pledge to introduce legislation this fall that advocates hope will make First Nations policing an essential service.

The broad strokes of the intention to bolster police services on First Nations was first announced by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2020, long before the fateful tragedies of Sept. 3, when a rampage by a man with a knife on James Smith Cree Nation in Saskatchewan ended with 10 people dead and 18 injured.

Related Articles

Governor General places tobacco on graves of Saskatchewan stabbing victims

Ottawa aims to table legislation this fall making Indigenous policing essential

James Smith Cree Nation chief to meet with federal ministers to discuss stabbings

Federal minister discusses First Nation policing, healing programs after stabbings

Indigenous Services minister attends funeral at site of mass killing in Saskatchewan

'Here to forgive': Victims' families, Indigenous leaders gather after mass stabbing

When the killing started, police were a 40-minute drive away. The attacker was long gone by the time RCMP arrived and it took three days for police to find Myles Sanderson.

The horrific events didn’t instigate the federal government’s determination to beef up on-reserve policing, but it certainly underlined its importance. First Nations leaders have long said that without adequate on-reserve policing, gangs and drug dealers can intimidate residents to the point where elders are scared to leave their homes.

Past efforts to establish on-reserve policing date back more than 30 years. The federal First Nations and Inuit Policing Program was created in 1991 to provide funding for reserve policing services, but the inadequacies of that program were detailed in a report released Sept. 21 by Mr. Mendicino.

It concluded, “Not enough funding is available in the overall program budget to adequately support each First Nations police service to do their work and to meet the expectations of the communities served.”

A key difference that could be a game-changer is making First Nation policing an essential service, which is the direction sought by groups consulted by Mr. Mendicino’s department. The classification of essential service would change the laws, and the obligations, of both provincial and federal governments and would ensure stable funding.

It’s an encouraging sign that of Ottawa’s budget allocation of more than $850 million over five years to support police in Indigenous communities, $43 million of that has been set aside to develop legislation that would recognize First Nations policing as an essential service.

Many details are still to be worked out. What will be the jurisdictional lines between First Nations police forces and the nearest RCMP detachments? Which First Nations communities will be chosen as hubs for a regional model of policing that includes other First Nations in the vicinity?

In what ways will the federal and provincial governments be involved in shaping standards and accountability for the public funding?

The answers to these questions and others should be developed in consultation with First Nations, Métis and Inuit representatives. Commendably, such consultation has already been a big part of the preliminary stages of Ottawa’s new policing proposal.

Discussions have focused on encouraging models in which police recruits would be chosen from among residents of the First Nations, which would groom homegrown officers who have cultural knowledge, solid leadership qualities and accountability to the community.

Ensuring First Nations receive the long-term resources to maintain stable policing is essential for self-governance. It’s about acknowledging law and order did not arrive with the settlers; that First Nations had long employed protective and enforcement structures that served them well. It’s about insisting this critical step toward reconciliation needs to be designated an essential service.