Cheers and jeers: why some bars must close, others allowed to stay open By: Malak Abas Posted: 7:00 PM CDT Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2020 Last Modified: 8:44 PM CDT Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2020 Updates

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 19/10/2020 (1431 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

While customers can raise a pint at Little Brown Jug, the doors of nearby King’s Head Pub, another popular Exchange District venue, are closed.

New rules that took effect in the Winnipeg region Monday to curb the spread of COVID-19 might have some patrons scratching their heads, but the decision about which businesses have to close boils down to one thing: their liquor licence.

There are six licences and each has its own set of rules and annual fee. So when the province announced Friday that beverage rooms and entertainment facilities had to close, that meant the King’s Head, which is a live music venue, had to pull the plug since it has an entertainment facility licence.

Even though Little Brown Jug has a different type of licence — unique hospitality — general manager Chantal Hogue said Friday’s announcement was confusing. Customers didn’t know if they’d be able to visit the brewery as of Monday.

“We did want to take the time to see if there was some subsequent announcement, because they didn’t name every type of industry that would have to close or just operate at 50 per cent capacity,” she said. “Thankfully, our taproom is already closed on Mondays, so we took that day to really reach out and get the information we needed.”

The William Avenue taproom is able to remain open at 50 per cent capacity, which is not a big change because its tables are spaced apart, Hogue said.

“I’m sure that everybody would always like a bit more information, but we’re able to operate without too many barriers, and we’re grateful for that,” she said.

On Monday, amid the confusion and anger expressed by business owners, the province switched gears and announced beverage rooms would be allowed to remain open. A beverage room licence authorizes a hotel to serve liquor. The hotel must have a minimum number of guest rooms to qualify for the licence. The change meant that Exchange District hotels such as the Woodbine and McLaren, could keep their beverage rooms open.

It made no difference to the King’s Head, which still has to stay closed for two weeks. Owner Chris Graves said he stopped offering live music because of new restrictions requiring licenced premises to not exceed 80 decibels, and it’s not possible to set up pool tables or games of darts in the building. There is, however, a full kitchen that will remain unused now.

“Because we hold the technical entertainment licence, we still can’t operate as a restaurant? That’s where the injustice is really happening right now,” he said.

The province’s shutdown targets live music venues, such as nightclubs, because patrons weren’t social distancing and virus numbers skyrocketed.

Just down the street, staff at the Peasant Cookery restaurant and bar are serving customers as usual. The business holds a dining room/lounge licence. Across the Board Café at 211 Bannatyne Ave. is also allowed to stay open and serve alcohol because it has a dining room licence.

Choosing which businesses can remain open based on their licence has created unfair situations, said Christian Stringer, owner of World Famous Palomino Club. The nightclub closed not long after “code orange” restrictions took effect in Winnipeg, because he said he “knew what was coming.”

The decision to close was a result of the requirement that no liquor be sold after 10 p.m. and customers be removed from licensed businesses by 11 p.m.

Stringer said that hurts nightclubs disproportionately.

“They changed their whole tune (Monday). We were all supposed to close down again, and then they changed it for (beverage rooms), but not us,” he said.

“We’re closed. Why? Because we don’t open till 9 p.m. or 10 p.m., we have to keep closed. The restrictions are totally different.”

A specific outline of restrictions focused on keeping people safe and providing rules customized for the unique needs of different businesses would be ideal, Stringer said.

“They’re not meant for nightclubs at all,” he said. “We’re just trying to stay alive.”

NDP Leader Wab Kinew said the province’s rollout of tightened restrictions frustrated patrons who couldn’t understand which businesses had to close.

“I think the average person is kind of scratching their head – the government’s parsing these terms like ‘beverage room,’ ‘lounge,’ ‘standalone nightclub’,” Kinew said.

“It’s a bit of a Swiss cheese of regulations in terms of what’s getting held back and what’s allowed to go ahead.”

— with files from Carol Sanders

malak.abas@freepress.mb.ca

Twitter: @malakabas_

Malak Abas
Reporter

Malak Abas is a reporter for the Winnipeg Free Press.

   Read full biography