Big ears, bigger jeers

Burton-directed Dumbo remake an artistic mess

Advertisement

Advertise with us

OK, going in, a confession: I’m not a fan of Disney’s live-action remakes of animated hits.

Read this article for free:

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Monthly Digital Subscription

$1 per week for 24 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on winnipegfreepress.com
  • Read the E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
  • Access News Break, our award-winning app
  • Play interactive puzzles

*Billed as $4 plus GST every four weeks. Offer only available to new and qualified returning subscribers. Cancel any time.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 30/03/2019 (2196 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

OK, going in, a confession: I’m not a fan of Disney’s live-action remakes of animated hits.

They seem simultaneously redundant and indulgent. Also, they feel vaguely heretical in the assumption that photorealistic computer animation is somehow superior to old-school cel animation.

So director Tim Burton’s version of Dumbo is pretty bad, but not because it dares to reinterpret a classic of Disney canon. (It’s not like there wasn’t room for improvement; pretty sure nobody will miss the racist shucking-and-jiving crows of the 1941 original.) No, it’s awful because it mindlessly sacrifices simplicity by layering on seemingly dozens of characters, needless complications of plot and the application of a madly rococo sensibility to production design.

Eva Green
Eva Green

At least Burton is consistent. He screws up Dumbo in precisely the same way he messed up Lewis Carroll’s adventures of Alice in Wonderland (as director) and Alice Through the Looking Glass (as producer) with a more-is-more ethos.

Burton and screenwriter Ehren Kruger dispense with any talking animals whatsoever this time out as we find ourselves in the decrepit travelling circus of Max Medici (Danny DeVito).

The year is 1919, and the once-flourishing show is a shabby, bare-bones affair. Returning to the fold after serving in the First World War is former trick rider Holt Farrier (Colin Farrell), now missing both his left arm and his wife. Holt’s missus died in the influenza epidemic earlier that year, we learn, leaving Holt to care for his two kids, the smart would-be scientist Milly (Nico Parker) and son Joe (Finley Hobbins), a kid so nondescript it feels like it slipped Kruger’s mind to give him a personality. (Both kids are essentially stand-ins for the supportive Timothy Q. Mouse from the original. Call it anthropomorphism in reverse.)

The horses are gone, so Holt is put in charge of the elephants.

He finds his hands full with Mrs. Jumbo, a new acquisition who promptly gives birth to Dumbo, a baby elephant whose overly large ears cause consternation for Max who, remember, presides over a freak show.

When Mrs. Jumbo hears her baby taunted by the crowds, she goes on a rampage, which results in her being sold off. The Farrier kids, relating to Dumbo’s motherless state, step in to take care of the baby elephant and discover his ears can facilitate flight.

Once Max realizes the possibilities, he is on the verge of making Dumbo a star attraction, when he is courted by the P.T. Barnum-like mega-showman V. A. Vandevere (Michael Keaton), who offers to make Max a partner in his new proto-theme park. All he has to do is partner Dumbo with the elegant French aerialist Collette Marchant (Eva Green).

Some of the elements of the screenplay are admirable. Trust Burton to turn the Walt Disney-esque showman Vandevere into a villain… in a Disney movie.

The script also comes out in favour of empowering young girls and against using animals in the circus. If the movie was a policy paper, you might be able to get behind it.

But artistically, it’s a mess. In the Alice movies, it was Johnny Depp who was given free rein to transform the Mad Hatter into a look-at-me star turn that pretty much derailed the movie. This time out, Keaton (who played Batman and Beetlejuice for Burton) is all over the map with his fluctuating accents and eccentric line readings.

Like Dumbo’s ears, Burton’s movie is just too big. Unlike Dumbo’s ears, his movie fails to take flight.

randall.king@freepress.mb.ca

Twitter: @FreepKing

Randall King

Randall King
Reporter

In a way, Randall King was born into the entertainment beat.

Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.

Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Report Error Submit a Tip

More Stories

Manitoba man, 25, sentenced for second killing; brother died in similar attack five years ago

Dean Pritchard 4 minute read Preview

Manitoba man, 25, sentenced for second killing; brother died in similar attack five years ago

Dean Pritchard 4 minute read 11:00 AM UTC

Five years after Roy Dunsford beat his brother to death in an alcohol-fuelled frenzy, his rage claimed the life of another victim — his mother.

Dunsford, 25, pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the May 2023 killing of 63-year-old Gillian Dunsford and was sentenced Wednesday to 18 years in prison.

“Other than Mr. Dunsford’s propensity for violence when intoxicated, there is no context or explanation for the killing,” said Court of King’s Bench Justice Chris Martin.

“This situation is yet another senseless tragedy in the seemingly unrelenting and dire record of heartbreaking circumstances of an Aboriginal man killing an Aboriginal woman,” he said.

Read
11:00 AM UTC
The Manitoba Law Courts building in Winnipeg on Wednesday, May 8, 2024. (John Woods /The Canadian Press files)

American clerics startled by their country’s intolerant shift seek safety for their families north of the border

John Longhurst 7 minute read Preview

American clerics startled by their country’s intolerant shift seek safety for their families north of the border

John Longhurst 7 minute read 7:01 AM UTC

Jonathan Stufft has plenty of faith, just not in his president and what’s happening to his country.

And he’s scared.

Stufft, 48, is an assistant to the bishop of the Northeastern Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. The 48-year-old Mansfield, Ohio, pastor is one of a half-dozen clerics from the progressive denomination who’ve contacted a forward-thinking Canadian organization to ask about ministry opportunities in Manitoba.

He told the Free Press he was in “utter shock” when Trump was elected a second time in November.

Read
7:01 AM UTC
SUPPLIED Jonathan Stufft

Stock markets in Canada and U.S. tumble after Trump tariff announcement

The Canadian Press 4 minute read Preview

Stock markets in Canada and U.S. tumble after Trump tariff announcement

The Canadian Press 4 minute read 10:30 AM UTC

TORONTO - Stock markets in Canada and the U.S. plunged in late-morning trading as investors reacted to the latest tariffs from U.S. President Donald Trump, while the loonie climbed higher compared with the U.S. dollar.

The S&P/TSX composite index was down 826.76 points or 3.2 per cent at 24,480.42 as markets worried the latest round of U.S. tariffs could sink the global economy into a recession.

In New York, the Dow Jones industrial average was down 1,447.65 points at 40,777.67. The S&P 500 index was down 233.69 points at 5,437.28, while the Nasdaq composite was down 951.96 points at 16,649.09.

The Canadian dollar traded for 71.26 cents US compared with 69.83 cents US on Wednesday.

Read
10:30 AM UTC
President Donald Trump speaks during an event to announce new tariffs in the Rose Garden at the White House, Wednesday, April 2, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein)

University of Winnipeg reaches major milestone with PhD-granting ability

Maggie Macintosh 6 minute read Preview

University of Winnipeg reaches major milestone with PhD-granting ability

Maggie Macintosh 6 minute read 11:00 AM UTC

The University of Winnipeg is touting the rollout of its first doctoral program as a way to recruit and retain more public-minded scientists in Manitoba.

Starting this fall, U of W is introducing a PhD in bioscience and policy — a major milestone for a campus that has long been known for its undergraduate options and has been funded accordingly.

Candidates are expected to conduct original research, reflect on its public value and learn how best to communicate their findings to a wider audience.

Craig Willis, a biology professor who has spent the better part of the last decade working on the proposal, said Manitoba has been an outlier because it has only one PhD-granting institution.

Read
11:00 AM UTC
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES The university’s new PhD program in bioscience and policy could put the cash-strapped school in line for research grants.

Passengers face fallout of WestJet dropping Winnipeg-Palm Springs route early

Gabrielle Piché 5 minute read Preview

Passengers face fallout of WestJet dropping Winnipeg-Palm Springs route early

Gabrielle Piché 5 minute read Tuesday, Apr 1, 2025

When WestJet unexpectedly canceled its direct flights from Winnipeg to Palm Springs a month early, travelers like James Derksen were left scrambling for alternatives.

Read
Tuesday, Apr 1, 2025
BROOK JONES/FREE PRESS FILE WestJet flew 13 less flights from Winnipeg to the U.S. in March compared to March 2024, per data from Cirium, an aviation analytics company.

Opinion: Stunning collapse in polls leaves Poilievre, Tories with little to do but hope Carney fumbles on way to goal line

Dan Lett 8 minute read Preview

Opinion: Stunning collapse in polls leaves Poilievre, Tories with little to do but hope Carney fumbles on way to goal line

Dan Lett 8 minute read Yesterday at 6:30 PM UTC

To pivot or not to pivot? That is the question facing Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre as he barrels towards the midway point in the federal election campaign.

You would think some sort of change in tack would be required. As just about everyone knows, Poilievre and his merry band of Tories squandered a 26-point lead in most opinion polls and are now solidly ensconced in second place among decided voters.

What has happened to the Conservatives is not just bizarre. It is unprecedented in Canadian political history.

However, the glass-half-full perspective for Conservatives is that there are still three-plus weeks left in the campaign, a long-enough period of time for the Tories to pivot and pull victory from the jaws of what seems like defeat right now. Unfortunately, that optimistic point of view ignores a fundamental problem facing Poilievre.

Read
Yesterday at 6:30 PM UTC
It seems unlikely at this point that Pierre Poilievre’s “Pierre from Canada” routine is going to make people forget about all the Trumpy things he said, Dan Lett writes. (Justin Tang/Canadian Press files)