More details needed in Manitoba response to Tina Fontaine report: advocate

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 07/10/2019 (1860 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

WINNIPEG – Manitoba’s advocate for youth says a lot more needs to be done if the government is to save children in care from the grim reality of an Indigenous teenage girl whose body was found in a river.

“Awareness is the first step,” says Daphne Penrose of her report released in March into Tina Fontaine’s death.

“The big question becomes: ‘What are you going to do to change the services for children and youth in Manitoba to make sure those situations don’t occur again?'”

Penrose’s report into Tina’s life and death outlined how social workers and others failed the girl even as it became clear she was spiralling downward and her life was at risk.

Tina was 15 when her body was found in the Red River flowing through Winnipeg five years ago.

The report included five recommendations touching on justice, education, mental health and child welfare. Penrose said at the time that the province needed to act quickly or more children would die.

The province committed to releasing updates publicly on its progress, but a report in June was not available until recently. Officials cited a pre-election blackout ahead of the Sept. 10 vote.

The update says the government has shared the advocate’s recommendation on changes to student suspensions and expulsions with a committee looking into education in the province.

It also says the province has ongoing reviews into youth mental-health services and how child welfare and the justice system are intertwined.

“We also know that simply increasing service funding is not the answer,” the update says.

“We must look at short-, medium- and long-term projects critically, so we can address … the needs of people seeking treatment now while building a stronger system in the months and years ahead.”

The Families Department says in an email that the government is reviewing feedback from the advocate’s office and will continue to provide regular updates on progress.

Tina’s mother was 17 and still a child in care when Tina was born. Both of her parents struggled with addictions. When Tina was five, she went to live with her great-aunt Thelma Favel from the Sagkeeng First Nation.

Tina’s life was relatively stable until her father was murdered in 2011. Favel, who was still her caregiver, tried to get her help through victim services. But Tina never received counselling.

In June 2014, Tina went to Winnipeg to reconnect with her mother. Tina was soon homeless, developed addictions and was sexually exploited. She reached out for help several times, but on more than one occasion there were no beds available.

Her 72-pound body, wrapped in a duvet cover and weighed down by rocks, was pulled from the river two months later.

Penrose says she’s been encouraged by actions taken by victim support services for children. One such initiative has been creating template letters to make sure information is clear and consistent for victims in traumatic situations in the justice system. Other positive changes have included expanding kits to help kids develop healthy coping strategies.

But many responses have been lacking in details, she says. Her office sent the government a slew of questions.

Penrose says she needs to know when reviews will be completed and has to have information on funding and other data to understand if the government is truly acting on the recommendations.

“To be able to monitor the compliance … allows us to ensure that these reports don’t sit on a shelf collecting dust.”

Penrose says she understands the government needs time to adapt, but she expects its progress reports to include more information in the future.

Manitobans need to know what’s being done to help children, she adds, so her office plans to begin publishing analyses of the government’s work online next month.

“The outcomes for kids can be quite dramatic and traumatic,” she says.

“It is important that we always continuously improve the services that are being provided to kids in their ever-changing world.”

This report for The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 8, 2019.

Read the report